Keys to a successful campaign

As a media provider, my team is often asked to answer marketers' questions like, "What's your average click-through rate on [X web ad placement]?" and "How many leads do you think we'll get if we run an ad in [Y newsletter]?" When I put myself in these marketers' shoes, I completely understand what they're trying to find out. These are good questions to ask.

But probably like many other media providers, we don't answer these questions with exact numbers. Sure, we're happy to provide a range so the marketer can get a feel for how well their ad might perform. But usually we'll present it in the context of "the best ads get X percent" (or X number of conversions) and "the worst ads get Y percent" (or Y number of conversions).

The reason we offer a high/low range is simple. In most situations, either the marketer or agency is controlling the creative message for the ads. During the buying process, when they're asking these types of questions, we have no idea how good (or bad) the creative will be. Well-designed, well-written, and well-thought-out campaigns will get much better results -- independent of the medium.

Even though it covers a lot of points all of us have heard before, this article by Harry Gold of ClickZ does a good job of reminding us of the keys to a successful creative execution. Start with the message and offer, then think about the landing page, and follow through to the post-action phase like confirmation pages and confirmation emails. Every step matters. Good ad creative can't overcome a bad landing page. A good landing page is useless if the creative message is wrong. And if a strong follow-up isn't in place, you're throwing away perfectly good opportunities.

One thing I'd like to add to Harry's article: Don't forget about what comes after these steps too. How will you nurture these leads? What's your sales team's approach for following up, taking the prospect through the sales cycle, and closing the sale? Often these tasks are not our job as marketers -- since this responsibility is passed along to sales in many companies. But if there's not a seamless plan in place, you know what happens. Leads and opportunities are lost, even if you did your job developing a successful advertising or marketing campaign.